May
I was in the process of writing a very long, very detailed criticism of President Obama’s choice of Sonia Sotomayor for the Supreme Court. I’ve given up.
Sure, I went into detail about her views that judging should be based on empathy, not on reason. I had plenty of quotes on how she has stated it impossible for the poor to overcome in the United States, even though that is exactly what she did. I was going to go into detail on how she believes sex and race play a part in the judicial process, sometimes overshadowing the law. I was also going to cover how she has a history of having her decision overturned and a lack of case review on her part. But, as I said, I’ve give up.
Why?
It is a fruitless effort.
It was clear Mr. Obama wanted specific type of person for the open Supreme Court position. All of the final choices were women, most with an “activist” agenda. He wasn’t interested in finding the right person for the job, he was looking for a label. It’s also clear that Republican’s cannot truly oppose her choice as they will be labeled racist.
That wouldn’t be the case – they would be opposing simply because she is not qualified and apparently biased in her role…but that is now how the press would spin it.
Think about this. What happens if you apply for a job that you are not qualified for?
Most likely, you are not going to get an interview let alone get the job. The second an institution starts picking people because of their age, sex and/or ethnic background creditability is instantly lost. If you are not picking the most qualified person available, why are you picking anyone at all?
This isn’t a political issue – she has had both Democratic and Republican support in her career – this is about doing the right thing. Based off of everything I’ve read in the last 12 hours, she is not the right choice. There are a number of highly qualified individuals, both men and women, would should be filling this role. Sonia Sotomayor is not one of those choice.