May
18
Posted (Van Santos) in Technology on May-18-2009

Every time a new search engine, with functionality different than The Google, comes to market people instantly declare “This is a Google Killer!”  Somehow a new, unknown, technology outfit is going to overtake the search giant simply because they do something in a different manner. Possible. Not likely.

The first time the “Google Killer” mantra was waved about came with the launch of Cuil.  Who?  Exactly.  This company claimed their technology would allow specific search results, in turn providing less clutter for the user. It didn’t. Forget even obtaining a 2rd tier search engine status – like Snap or Gigablast – Cuil has faded into history as a sub-standard search engine that happened to ride a quick marketing wave.

Fast-forward a few years and enter Wolfram Alpha.

Here we have a new technology, a new search engine that is “computational”.  This search engine does not go out and spider the web looking for result, instead Wolfram Alpha uses an internal knowledge base to generate results (and does so impressively, I may add).

When Google first started, one of the main user groups seemed to be developers/geeks/scientists as the service the engine provided directed one to results with no crap.  You needed to understand how a specific function python worked, Google found the answer – back then, there was usually only one or two – and you could be on your way.  This is exactly what I see Wolfram Alpha as.  A tool/application for “hardcore” users.

I suspect the casual, everyday user will find little use in Wolfram Alpha at first glance.  Spend some time playing around, understanding the technology, and the value becomes apparent almost immediately.

Let’s be realistic, the next “it” application doesn’t simply appear over night. It’s in the wild for some time before the masses even realize. In no way is this new service a Google Killer but, in due time, this has the potential to be a significant Google competitor.

Related posts:

  1. Microsoft to unveil a new search engine?
  2. Interesting concept – Twitter Search Engine Twithority launches
  3. Google to release web browser – Google Chrome
  4. Hey Google, Don't Be Evil
  5. Quick First Impressions – Google Chrome

Comments:
SamuraiMarine on May 20th, 2009 at 11:47 pm #

You know… not to defend their position, but it stands to reason that if enough people over a long enough period of time come forward and state that they are the “Google Killer.” One day, one of them might be right.

Who knows… WA certain LOOKS pretty… and there are people that might swear by it for a while, or forever… forever being subjective as long as it should last.

One never can tell.

Van Santos on May 21st, 2009 at 7:57 am #

I don’t doubt their ability to compete, as they have amazing quick and accurate, results, but in their current format I don’t see how they would take The Google on for *every day* searching.

Now, that said, they could expand their knowledge base and target more users, but if someone is searching for – say – a flash drive, WA won’t show them anything as of now.

This requires people to think differently, and that is what I doubt the most about the using public. It seems people just want to point and go.

You are right, something may change and they may actually become that google killer. Under the current format, I have doubts.

SamuraiMarine on May 21st, 2009 at 9:07 pm #

Here… I did not see that you had this… If they are able to achieve what they are selling in this video, then I WILL be impressed with it.

http://www.wolframalpha.com/screencast/introducingwolframalpha.html

Van Santos on May 21st, 2009 at 9:30 pm #

WOW. Seriously even more impressive than what I had experienced.

Do you think the engine can make people think in terms of useful questions (or that pertain to the data input for the search?)

Thanks for that.

SamuraiMarine on May 21st, 2009 at 10:57 pm #

Well… I spent an hour typing in questions along the lines of what he did in that video, and none of what I put in there worked… so obviously he was working with a set of questions that he KNEW would give impressive answers.

Unless the engine is built to go out and hunt this information down by itself, I do not see how they will be able to build the database with that much cross-medium support.

Post a comment
Name: 
Email: 
URL: 
Comments: