Ok, I have very, very low hopes about this movie mainly because it was Tom Cruise. To me, when I see Tom Cruise in a part – I see Tom Cruise – I do not see the character he is playing. I have the same problem with Ray Liotta. However, in Valkyrie that was not the case…
What surprised me the most about the film is the cast, we are talking about a great supporting lineup. Kenneth Branagh, Bill Nighy, Tom Wilkinson, Terence Stamp and Eddie Izzard were all superb in their roles. While Branagh, Izzard and Stamp do not get huge amounts of screen time, when they did have the focus they made it count. At the very end, when Branagh’s character decides to pick the option he did (not giving anything away for those who will see the movie), I believed every moment… I actually felt the tension.
Bryan Singer, the director – and of Xmen fame – did an OK job at recreating World War Two Germany. While the sets where limited due to the story, it was believable. I was impressed with the design and layout of Hitler’s Wolf’s Lair. Being a fan of history it was nice to see that some attention was given to the detail of this set, from bunker design to sidewalks, the design represented what the area looked like – not a Hollywood version of what they thought it would look like.
What I did have a problem with, however, was the lack of swastikas on the troops – specifically the German Officers. Instead of military wearing arm bands, we had the military walking around in Gray suits with the swastikas turned into a nondescript pledge pin. The whole point of the swastika was to remind the German people who they were, removing this vital aspect of history almost makes it feel as if Singer is trying to remove the Nazi aspect from his version of history. This is a dangerous road for Hollywood to travel because it has the ability to lead to revisionist history.
Speaking of history, the movie was hit and miss. Claus Schenk Graf von Stauffenberg, Cruise’s character, had attempted to kill Hitler 3 times before – not once. Also, the number of assassination attempts listed by the movie, in total, is low. There were 42 known attempts on Hitlers life.
Others have complained about the fact that no German accents really showed up in the movie, and I have no problem with that. Let’s face it, this is no “Saving Private Ryan”. We all know how the story ends, but what the movie does a good job at doing is putting the tension into the story. It also makes you question “what if” a few people made other decisions.
Overall, a good movie. I’ll go 7.5/10